Search Media Releases

Archives, by date

19

High Court finds Coalition pay equity changes breached women's rights

A High Court ruling today that the Coalition Government's changes to pay equity breach the Bill of Rights shows the new scheme is unjust, unfair and must be urgently reversed, NZNO says. 

The final judgment handed down today by the High Court at Wellington (attached) found that women working in undervalued female dominated workforces have been subjected to "unjustified discrimination on the basis of their sex".  

NZNO delegate and aged care health care assistant Lisa Marriner says today's decision vindicates health workers who had their claim taken from them without consultation or notice on 6 May 2025.  

"The Court today said what we've known all along. What the Government did to us was wrong. They robbed low-paid women and their whanau so they could balance their books while caregivers are left struggling to pay their bills and fighting for small increases to already low wages. 

"Today we've been heard. 

"The next government must change the law and restore the 33 cancelled pay equity claims covering 180,000 workers, most of them women, in the first 100 days in office," Lisa Marriner says. 

NZNO delegate and Plunket nurse Hannah Cook says the Coalition Government took away a world-leading system and replaced it with a "sham scheme".  

"NZNO has tested the new law by raising claims for Plunket, Hospice and Bupa nurses. Our experience has exposed that the new system is unworkable. The Coalition Government promised the new system is a pathway to pay equity but our claims have been blocked by their own agency, Te Whatu Ora.  

"We did what they asked, we started again under their new rules and raised our claim again. We met the merit test, but we've still been blocked. Now the new Government has to put this right. 

"Pay free from gender-based discrimination is a fundamental human right. Women, our families, our daughters and our granddaughters to come deserve no less,” Hannah Cook says. 

Background: 

  • The High Court case was filed in August 2025 by NZNO alongside four other unions; the Public Service Association, the Post-Primary Teachers' Association, NZEI Te Riu Roa and the Tertiary Education Union. 

  • The ruling means the Attorney-General must report the breach of the Bill of Rights Act to Parliament, and the Government must formally respond. 

  • Findings that the Bill of Rights has been breached are rare and have only been handed down by the courts in four other cases. 

Direct Media Enquiries To:

Please send all media requests in writing to media@nzno.org.nz.

NZNO's communications and media team is:

Danya Levy (Communications manager)
Danya.Levy@nzno.org.nz
027 431 2617  |  04 494 8242

Samesh Mohanlall (Media and Communications advisor)
samesh.mohanlall@nzno.org.nz
021 240 3420  |  04 494 6839

Support and member enquiries: 0800 28 38 48 or nurses@nzno.org.nz